Why your house is a terrible investment, according to JL Collins

Video ID: wdstqPqZI5k

YouTube URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wdstqPqZI5k

Added At: 28-06-25 23:55:15

Processed: No

Sentiment: Neutral

Categories: Finance, Self-Help

Tags: investing, financial literacy, house buying, wealth creation, lifestyle choice

Summary

["The author argues that buying a house is not an investment, but rather a lifestyle choice.","Owning a house comes with significant expenses, including mortgage, real estate taxes, and maintenance.","The author suggests that building wealth through investing in assets like VTSAX (a Vanguard index fund) may be a better option than buying a house."]

Transcript

You wrote a blog post called Why Your
House is a terrible Investment and then
you hit publish. Half the internet
turned on you. Two questions. Number
one, why do people get so worked up
about this issue? And number two, why is
my house a terrible investment?
 Your
house is a terrible investment because
it's basically is not an investment.
Right? You shouldn't think of your house
as an investment. Sometimes it works
out. It goes up in value, but it's a
place to live. It's a lifestyle choice,
right? So you need to separate in your
mind uh what an investment is and and
what a house is. So you know when you
invest in a house you're taking on
enormous expenses. You've got your
mortgage which everybody thinks of and
they say oh you know I can buy this
house and the mortgage is no more than
my rent. And they're forgetting
conveniently about well there's real
estate taxes right and then there's all
the maintenance and repairs on it and
you going to buy the house and not
remodel the kitchen. You're never going
to remodel the kitchen in your
apartment, but you know, very few people
buy a house and don't start immediately
changing it. You're going to buy
furniture for it. You're going to buy
appliances for it. It's never ending.
And all that's fine. You know, money's
can be used for a lot of things. I've
owned houses most of my adult life. I'm
not saying don't own a house. Saying
don't confuse yourself thinking it's an
investment. Your house and my house are
both actively trying to return to dust
in the earth, right? And we have to
spend copious amounts of time and money
preventing that from happening.
 But what
about I'm building equity. Why should I
give that money to a bank? And what
about the idea that what are you telling
millennials to do? Just own nothing.
Millennials and zoomers should own
nothing and let Black Rockck have all
that money.
 Oh, I'm not saying you
should own nothing. I'm saying you
should own assets. You should own VTSAX.
You know, my daughter,
 you really
believe you're telling everybody on the
internet right now that's my age or
younger VTSAX and rent?
 Yes. And that's
what I tell my daughter. And that's what
she's doing. She's in her early 30s. She
just quit her corporate job uh last
fall. I don't know if that's permanent
or or if it's just a temporary IAS, but
she at least has you money the way we
defined it earlier that she can make
that kind of bold decision cuz she
didn't make any silly decisions like
buying a house and becoming house poor
and being dependent on a paycheck to pay
for all of those things. So yeah, if
building wealth is your key goal, then
no, owning a house is is not going to
contribute to that. If on the other
hand, you want to own a house because
it'll provide a certain lifestyle that
you're you find desirable, maybe a yard
for your kids or whatever, then that
that's great. That's a lifestyle
decision. It's not a financial decision.